|November 16th, 2012, 10:10 AM||#1|
Joined: Feb 2011
From: New Jersey, USA
Our election system: fair or not
Electing the US president; how to
To simplify the matter, assume there are only 7 states
State A counts as 5 votes (based on population of that state) Majority voted for X
State B counts as 4 votes ( based on ...). Majority in that state voted for Y
State C counts as 9 votes (based on ... ). Majority in that state voted for X
State D counts as 6 votes (based on ...). Majority in that state voted for Y
State E counts as 14 votes (based on ...) Majority in that state voted for X
State F counts as 6 votes ( based on ...) Majority in that state voted for Y
State G counts as 21 votes (based on ... ) Majority in that state voted for Y
X received 5+9+14=28 votes and Y received 4+6+6+21=37 votes. Y is the winner.
* * *
I do not know why this system is called "Electoral College." In fact, the word "college" confused me for a long time. What does it have to do with colleges in which we study?
Suppose the president is elected by the sytem called "popular vote," used in some other countries.
In that case votes of individual citizens are counted, as illustrated below (this is also a simplification).
State A ==> 22 million voted for X and 3 million voted for Y.
State B ==> 4 million voted for X and 5 million voted for Y.
State C ==> 9 million voted for X and 13 million voted for Y.
State D ==> 12 million voted for X and 3 million voted for Y.
State E ==> 8 million voted for X and 23 million voted for Y.
State F ==> 2 million voted for X and 3 million voted for Y.
State G ==> 11 million voted for X and 8 million voted for Y.
X ==> 22+4+9+12+8+2+11=68 million
Y ==> 3+5+13+3+23+3+8 =58 million
In this case X is the winner. Is this fair or not? See:
| || |
|November 16th, 2012, 02:02 PM||#2|
Joined: Jan 2009
It was the intention of the founding fathers to create a constitutional republic and not a democracy. A wise move I would say. A democracy run by popular vote gives you tyranny by majority. A republic gives more voice to the minority.
|November 16th, 2012, 02:16 PM||#3|
Joined: Nov 2012
The Liberal states continuously whine about the electoral college not directly reflecting the popular vote. But, even though they're free to split their electoral votes according to their state's popular vote, they refuse to do so.
|election , fair , system|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|What tax system do you prefer?||myp||Economics||110||December 6th, 2011 12:57 AM|
|The ?Fair tax? can only be passed incrementally||Supposn||Economics||6||September 6th, 2010 07:59 PM|
|Was Amanda Knox given a fair trial?||omej||Current Events||6||December 21st, 2009 10:58 PM|
|USA Medical System||Rick||Government and Politics||8||January 19th, 2009 10:11 PM|