Question for Christians #3

Aug 2011
758
0
Many people pray to God for help with their problems. Yet some prayers appear to answered, but some are not. Why shouldn't all be answered?
 
Jul 2009
5,893
474
Port St. Lucie
Many people pray to God for help with their problems. Yet some prayers appear to answered, but some are not. Why shouldn't all be answered?

Do you say yes to every favor asked? Plenty of deep questions to be asked (and you're asking some of them) but this isn't 1 of them. :p
 
Aug 2011
758
0
Do you say yes to every favor asked? Plenty of deep questions to be asked (and you're asking some of them) but this isn't 1 of them.

I can't grant every favor because I'm not God. God, being all-powerful, can. You're not suggesting God can run out of favors - are you?
 
Jul 2009
5,893
474
Port St. Lucie
I can't grant every favor because I'm not God. God, being all-powerful, can. You're not suggesting God can run out of favors - are you?

You've never been asked a favor, within your ability to give, that you refused?
 
Aug 2011
76
0
I don't think that's the true power of prayer. Prayer should be more meditation: maybe God hears someone when they reach their moment of zen, so to speak.
 
Aug 2011
758
0
Proper prayer is in saying "Not my will, but thy will be done."

If that's so, then many people are probably confused over its purpose, as they ask for cures for disease, etc. Also, God doesn't need anyone to encourage that He does His will - He will anyway - won't He?
 
Aug 2011
448
0
California
If that's so, then many people are probably confused over its purpose, as they ask for cures for disease, etc. Also, God doesn't need anyone to encourage that He does His will - He will anyway - won't He?

We pray that mankind will do his will, something that mankind has a dismal record of.

As for people seeking cures: Again, if it is his will. But, suffering has a redemptive value, something that our medicated society cannot grasp. Mankind always excels during times of adversity, and likewise he ususally gets apathetic during good times. Suffering can bring about amazing good things whci may not be apparent right off the bat.
 
Aug 2011
758
0
We pray that mankind will do his will, something that mankind has a dismal record of.

As for people seeking cures: Again, if it is his will. But, suffering has a redemptive value, something that our medicated society cannot grasp. Mankind always excels during times of adversity, and likewise he ususally gets apathetic during good times. Suffering can bring about amazing good things whci may not be apparent right off the bat.

A five year old kid dies of cancer, after suffering for awhile. What exactly is redemptive about that?
 
Aug 2011
448
0
California
A five year old kid dies of cancer, after suffering for awhile. What exactly is redemptive about that?

What if his parents use that as motivation to start a cancer foundation that ends up curing millions of kids?

What if that incident turns them to God, and they in turn turn others to God? What if the kid himself, in his pain, turns to God in a way he had not before?

The possibile ripple effects are countless. Your "whats in it for me" outlook is too myopic and stems from a POV of selfishness.
 
Aug 2011
758
0
What if his parents use that as motivation to start a cancer foundation that ends up curing millions of kids?

What if that incident turns them to God, and they in turn turn others to God? What if the kid himself, in his pain, turns to God in a way he had not before?

The possibile ripple effects are countless. Your "whats in it for me" outlook is too myopic and stems from a POV of selfishness.

What if the parents DON'T start a foundation? Then what was the point? Also, if cancer didn't exist, which surely God can arrange, there wouldn't be any need for such foundations, would there?
 
Jul 2011
53
0
I think the film Bruce Almighty covers this topic. I know it is meant to be comical and have the entertainment factor it does show us that having everything isn't always amazing as well always getting what we pray for isn't going to solve life's problems.
 
Aug 2011
758
0
I think the film Bruce Almighty covers this topic. I know it is meant to be comical and have the entertainment factor it does show us that having everything isn't always amazing as well always getting what we pray for isn't going to solve life's problems.

It would solve MILLIONS of problems!
 
Jan 2010
131
0
Alaska
Many people pray to God for help with their problems. Yet some prayers appear to answered, but some are not. Why shouldn't all be answered?


First, the prayers of Christians.

John 15:7 says "If you remain in me and my words remain in you, ask whatever you wish, and it will be given you".


Matthew 17:20 says, "I tell you the truth, if you have faith as small as a mustard seed, you can say to this mountain, ‘Move from here to there’ and it will move. Nothing will be impossible for you."
Mark 9:23 says "everything is possible for him who believes".

And Matthew 6:14 "For if you forgive men when they sin against you, your heavenly Father will also forgive you."

So if you truly believe and have faith, and you forgive others, your prayer is answered. The problem is that some do not have faith, really believe, or are living in sin (such as not forgiving others).

Second, the prayers of non-Christians.

1 Peter 3:12 - "For the eyes of the Lord are on the righteous and his ears are attentive to their prayer, but the face of the Lord is against those who do evil"

John 9:31 - We know that God does not listen to sinners. He listens to the godly man who does his will.

God does not hear the prayers of nonbelievers.
 
Feb 2011
299
0
Canada
What if his parents use that as motivation to start a cancer foundation that ends up curing millions of kids?

What if that incident turns them to God, and they in turn turn others to God? What if the kid himself, in his pain, turns to God in a way he had not before?

The possibile ripple effects are countless. Your "whats in it for me" outlook is too myopic and stems from a POV of selfishness.

Why doesn't God simply snap his fingers, and end cancer once and for all? After all, HE created cancer in the first place. This would make him a mass-murderer, and you would seek to follow such an evil being?
 
Aug 2011
758
0
First, the prayers of Christians.

John 15:7 says "If you remain in me and my words remain in you, ask whatever you wish, and it will be given you".


Matthew 17:20 says, "I tell you the truth, if you have faith as small as a mustard seed, you can say to this mountain, ‘Move from here to there’ and it will move. Nothing will be impossible for you."
Mark 9:23 says "everything is possible for him who believes".

And Matthew 6:14 "For if you forgive men when they sin against you, your heavenly Father will also forgive you."

So if you truly believe and have faith, and you forgive others, your prayer is answered. The problem is that some do not have faith, really believe, or are living in sin (such as not forgiving others).

Second, the prayers of non-Christians.

1 Peter 3:12 - "For the eyes of the Lord are on the righteous and his ears are attentive to their prayer, but the face of the Lord is against those who do evil"

John 9:31 - We know that God does not listen to sinners. He listens to the godly man who does his will.

God does not hear the prayers of nonbelievers.

So all the people whose prayers went unanswered are non-believers?
 
Jan 2012
1,975
5
Texas
I find myself daily thanking God for not answering some of my prayers, father knows best.

If I had a less vague answer to this question, I think that I would be God.
 
Aug 2011
758
0
I find myself daily thanking God for not answering some of my prayers, father knows best.

If I had a less vague answer to this question, I think that I would be God.

What about the people who prayed for a cure for a child with cancer, but the child died anyway - were the prayers inappropriate?
 
Top