Turkey’s miscarriage of justice

Jun 2012
134
0
Turkey
Dani Rodrik is a professor of international political economy at Harvard University’s John F. Kennedy School of Government.

After a patently sham trial, a Turkish court on Friday handed down lengthy jail sentences to more than 300 military officers convicted of planning a coup, code-named Sledgehammer, in 2003.

Turkey’s courts have been working overtime to throw government opponents of all political stripes behind bars. Since 2007, the government has run a series of trials against an alleged ultra-nationalist terrorist organization called Ergenekon, charging lawyers, politicians, academics, journalists and military officers with plotting to overthrow the government. In separate cases, thousands of Kurdish politicians and activists are on trial — nearly 1,000 among them detained — for alleged links with terrorist activities. Turkey holds more journalists in jail than China and Iran combined.

In terms of sheer drama, few match the Sledgehammer case. In a trial that began in 2010, 365 serving and retired high-ranking military officials — including my father-in-law, Çetin Dogan — and two civilians are charged with planning the coup. Prosecutors allege that the plotters planned to bomb mosques, down a Turkish fighter jet in a false-flag operation, take over hospitals and pharmacies, close nongovernmental organizations, arrest journalists and politicians, and ultimately appoint a handpicked cabinet.

For more http://www.washingtonpost.com/opini...125276-033d-11e2-8102-ebee9c66e190_story.html

I often see that international media systematically advertise Turkey as a western democratic country with the predominant Muslim population, especially during the Arab spring, it made Turkey a model for those countries that looking to form up a new system.

But generally these comments and articles does not reflect the truth at all.

And I've found one of the rarely seen articles about the ongoing political convictions.
 
Last edited:
Jul 2009
5,893
474
Port St. Lucie
Dani Rodrik is a professor of international political economy at Harvard University’s John F. Kennedy School of Government.

After a patently sham trial, a Turkish court on Friday handed down lengthy jail sentences to more than 300 military officers convicted of planning a coup, code-named Sledgehammer, in 2003.

Turkey’s courts have been working overtime to throw government opponents of all political stripes behind bars. Since 2007, the government has run a series of trials against an alleged ultra-nationalist terrorist organization called Ergenekon, charging lawyers, politicians, academics, journalists and military officers with plotting to overthrow the government. In separate cases, thousands of Kurdish politicians and activists are on trial — nearly 1,000 among them detained — for alleged links with terrorist activities. Turkey holds more journalists in jail than China and Iran combined.

In terms of sheer drama, few match the Sledgehammer case. In a trial that began in 2010, 365 serving and retired high-ranking military officials — including my father-in-law, Çetin Dogan — and two civilians are charged with planning the coup. Prosecutors allege that the plotters planned to bomb mosques, down a Turkish fighter jet in a false-flag operation, take over hospitals and pharmacies, close nongovernmental organizations, arrest journalists and politicians, and ultimately appoint a handpicked cabinet.

For more http://www.washingtonpost.com/opini...125276-033d-11e2-8102-ebee9c66e190_story.html

I often see that international media systematically advertise Turkey as a western democratic country with the predominant Muslim population, especially during the Arab spring, it made Turkey a model for those countries that looking to form up a new system.

But generally these comments and articles does not reflect the truth at all.

And I've found one of the rarely seen articles about the ongoing political convictions.

Turkey is NATO, has a vary powerful military and would probally go to Iran if if we cut them lose. Are you supprise the West plays nice?
 
May 2012
215
37
The motherland
The military has been a part of the Turkish establishment for decades as the defender of the secular state and it launched three coups in the past and it played a crucial role in the fall of the Islamist government in 1997 and it's not surprising that if there was a coup attempt in 2003 to topple the Erdogan government given the nature of Erdogan's AK party. Dani Rodrik is a son-in-law of one of the convicted generals and his view on the verdict may not be impartial.
 
Last edited:
Jun 2012
134
0
Turkey
The military has been a part of the Turkish establishment for decades as the defender of the secular state and it launched three coups in the past and it played a crucial role in the fall of the Islamist government in 1997 and it's not surprising that if there was a coup attempt in 2003 to topple the Erdogan government given the nature of Erdogan's AK party. Dani Rodrik is a son-in-law of one of the convicted generals and his view on the verdict may not be impartial.

Not true. Every coup has different goals. İnstance, the 1980's coup's aim was to destroy all socialist movements. As an antidote of the left philosophy, they used religion a lot and opened new religious schools. It was aganist the Democratic Left Party's administration. Already the AKP also is a result of this coup.


Maybe Dani Rodik but numbers are not son-in law of anybody. There are more coup trials now, journalists, trade unionists, soldiers, doctors, politicans, writers are waiting for a decision as arrested since almost three years. And all their crime is opposing to the rulling party. Reporters Without Borders has also works on the arrested journalists. Even if there would be a real coup plan due to the a few soldier, it doesn't change the reality of many people blamed and arrested for their democratic actions.

About 1000 people in Ergenekon trial and Almost 2000 people in KCK trial spending their years in prisons without any verdict.


One thing I'm almost sure, Yargıtay(Turkish Supreme Court) or European Court of Human Rights will break the most part of this verdict that made up during to the trials. But these people will spend many years in prison as inevitable if this government doesn't change in next election.

Turkey needs an independent judiciary.

Turkey is NATO, has a vary powerful military and would probally go to Iran if if we cut them lose. Are you supprise the West plays nice?

We have an idiom. ''can't run a mill by transporting water from away'' I hope it became an understandable translation. Good advertising is not providing democracy really.
 
Last edited:
Jul 2009
5,893
474
Port St. Lucie
We have an idiom. ''can't run a mill by transporting water from away'' I hope it became an understandable translation. Good advertising is not providing democracy really.

I'm not saying Turkey has a healthy democracy, I'm saying the West ather have a modate, pro-West verson of Iran then Iran*2 and a resurgent Ottoman Empire (becuase an anti-West, Islamic Turkey would make a move on the Lavent, they'd have little to lose and a poweful empire to regain).
 
Top